Author: Twaambo Chirwa, 22 October 2025,
To Buy or To Rent?

To Buy or To Rent? The Current Market Sentiment

Johannesburg’s property market is buzzing with questions as we head out of Spring and into the run-up to year-end. With interest rates edging down, inflation showing signs of easing and rental demand still pressing high, many Joburgers are wondering: do I keep renting or finally take the leap into ownership?

This isn’t just a financial decision -  it’s about lifestyle, security and timing. Let’s break down what the numbers are telling us, what the sentiment feels like on the ground and how a simple cost comparison plays out in the city’s most in-demand suburbs.

Rates, Inflation and the Mood of the Market

The South African Reserve Bank has brought the prime lending rate down to - and as at September 18 2025 was holding it steady at - 10.5 %, with economists hinting at a further cut before the end of the year, if inflation stays in check. That’s a shift from the heavier borrowing costs of 2022 - when it was 11.75 - and then the steady downward trend across 2023 - 2025; and it’s nudging more buyers back into the market.

For households in Johannesburg, this means mortgages are becoming more manageable -  but they’re not the only cost to consider. Add in property rates, levies and maintenance and the true monthly cost is higher than the bank’s repayment figure. Still, the psychological shift is clear: lower rates spark confidence.

Meanwhile, renters are feeling the pinch. Although Gauteng’s rental growth isn’t as steep as Cape Town’s, Joburg’s prime areas -  Bryanston, Sandton, The Parks, Midrand -  are seeing landlords push through increases. Rental yields remain healthy for investors, which often translates into upward pressure on rents for tenants.


Renting in Johannesburg: Freedom, but at a Price


Renting is still the go-to for young professionals, newcomers to the city or anyone who prizes flexibility. You avoid transfer duties, deposits the size of a small fortune and the headache of maintenance like burst geysers or broken electric gates. You can move suburbs with relative ease -  a big plus in a city where traffic and work commutes often reshape lives.

But that freedom comes with its own cost. Rental escalations in the 5–8 % range eat into budgets fast. Over five years, tenants may find themselves paying far more than they expected, especially if they stay put in one home. And there’s no equity at the end -  those payments build someone else’s asset, not yours.


Buying: Security and Equity, with Heavy Upfront Costs


On the other side of the coin, buying in Johannesburg offers stability. Owning a townhouse in Midrand, a sectional title apartment in Rosebank or a family home in Bryanston means you’re investing in yourself, not your landlord. Even modest annual property price growth of 5 - 6 % compounds significantly over five years.

This is also where services like a free home valuation Bryanston can be useful, giving sellers a clear picture of market value before making their next move. For homeowners looking to sell my luxury home Johannesburg, understanding these shifts in costs and buyer demand can help time the sale.

But ownership is no light undertaking. Deposits of 10 - 20 % are standard, bond approval is still strict and transfer costs can sting. Monthly repayments on a R1.5 million property, even at today’s rates, land around R14,000 - R15,000 -  before rates, insurance and levies. That can push the true cost closer to R16,000 - R18,000 per month.

Compared to renting a similar property at R12,000 - R14,000, buying is more expensive in the short term. But once you factor in appreciation and the principal you chip off the bond each month, the medium- to long-term scales start to tilt.


The Five-Year Snapshot


Take a middle-market case study:

  • Buying a R1.5m townhouse today, with a 20 % deposit, will cost about R900,000 in repayments and upkeep over five years. In return, you could see your property’s value climb toward R1,75m, with a sizable chunk of equity built in.
  • Renting the same home at R12,000 per month, escalating at 6 % annually, will cost around R811,000 over five years. In the end, you walk away with no asset -  but you would also have avoided the stress and risks of ownership.

The numbers suggest that if you’re settled and stable, ownership is worth the heavier monthly hit. If your career, lifestyle or finances are less certain, renting keeps you flexible.


What Matters Most in Johannesburg Right Now

  1. Location still trumps everything. Growth corridors like Midrand and Fourways benefit from new infrastructure and family-friendly demand, while Bryanston offers suburban luxury with depth - larger homes, school proximity, leafy streets and a strong sense of community - and Rosebank and Sandton continue to attract urban professionals seeking convenience and lifestyle.

For sellers in these hotspots, working with the best estate agents for selling homes can make all the difference, especially when aiming to sell property fast Fourways or position a luxury listing to the right buyers.

  1. Security and lifestyle weigh heavily. Gated estates, lock-up-and-go apartments and properties near schools and malls hold their value best.
  2. Sentiment is cautiously optimistic. Buyers sense a window of opportunity before rates rise again, while renters worry about another round of escalations.

Who Should Rent, Who Should Buy

And for sellers, even if you’re not buying again immediately, small touches like staging and applying luxury home selling tips South Africa can help achieve a quicker, more profitable sale.

Looking Ahead to Summer


As Johannesburg rolls into Summer, optimism will be tested by reality. Will the SARB cut again before year-end? Will landlords push through another round of increases in January? And will buyers sitting on the fence finally commit before housing prices climb further?

The truth is, there’s no universal answer. Renting offers flexibility and short-term affordability. Buying builds wealth and stability but requires heavy upfront commitment. The right move depends on your financial readiness, your life stage and - perhaps most importantly in Joburg -  the suburb that feels like home.



Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only and does not constitute financial or legal advice. Readers should seek guidance from a qualified professional before making property or investment decisions.


Choose Homes of Distinction to Sell your home

Listing your home with Homes of Distinction means partnering with an experienced team that understands the nuances of the real estate market. Our agents are experts in showcasing properties, ensuring that your home receives the attention it deserves. Whether you’re seeking a Free home valuation Bryanston, planning to sell my luxury home Johannesburg, or looking for the Best estate agents for selling homes, our team has the insight and network to deliver results. With our proven strategies, high-quality marketing and personalised service, we help you navigate the selling process with ease and  efficiency. From clients who need to sell property fast Fourways to those searching for Luxury home selling tips South Africa, we provide guidance tailored to your goals. Trust Homes of Distinction to guide you through every step, from pricing and staging to final negotiations, ensuring a smooth and successful sale of your property. Let us turn your selling goals into reality.

Are you looking to buy or sell your property? Visit our website at https://www.homesofdistinction.co.za/

Sign up for our newsletter: - https://www.homesofdistinction.co.za/newsletter/ or pop by our offices for a chat. Our friendly property practitioners are always available to assist in this regard.

Homes of Distinction CC holds a Fidelity Fund Certificate issued by the Property Practitioners Regulatory Authority (PPRA).