What Sells a Home? A: The Right Price
There are countless articles offering tips on how to sell your home faster: declutter, stage it, paint it neutral, light a few scented candles, mow the lawn... the list goes on. And while presentation absolutely matters, there is one truth in real estate that consistently holds up, regardless of season or suburb: The right price sells a house.
It's a deceptively simple principle but one that many sellers struggle with, often to their detriment. In this article, we explore why pricing is the single most influential factor in a successful property sale, why emotional attachment can be a seller's worst enemy and how to approach pricing with clarity and strategy.
A buyer's market vs a seller's market
Understanding the broader property climate is crucial before setting a price. In a seller's market, demand outpaces supply, so properties often fetch higher prices and sell quickly. In a buyer's market - which South Africa has experienced more of in recent years - supply exceeds demand. Buyers have the upper hand, more choice and stronger negotiating power.
This means that wishful thinking won't sell a house. Price sensitivity is amplified in a buyer's market and buyers are incredibly well-informed, thanks to the ease in accessing online property platforms and comparative tools. They're not just viewing one property - they're scrutinising dozens, comparing features, finishes and especially price per square metre. Almost as easy as placing a grocery order for delivery in 60 minutes
With inflationary pressure and interest rate fluctuations also affecting affordability, buyers are becoming even more selective. If your home isn't priced in alignment with perceived value, they'll simply keep scrolling.
The psychology of overpricing
Many homeowners begin their journey by saying, "We'll start a bit high and see what happens. We can always drop the price later." It feels safe - you never want to leave money on the table, after all.
But here's the problem: your home gets the most attention in the first few weeks it hits the market. That window is your moment of greatest visibility and impact. If it's overpriced, it gets overlooked. The listing goes stale and buyers begin to wonder what's wrong with it.
Eventually, after a few price reductions, you might get some interest. But by then, you've wasted valuable time, possibly lost out on motivated buyers and likely accepted an offer lower than what you could have achieved had you priced it correctly from the start.
In short: overpricing doesn't protect your investment. It risks diminishing it. Worse still, the longer a property sits unsold, the more it can stigmatise the home. Properties with "price reduced" banners or long listing times tend to get passed over in favour of newer listings - even if the price becomes more competitive.
Emotions vs Economics
One of the hardest aspects of selling a home is detaching from it emotionally. It might be where you raised your children, celebrated birthdays, built a life. But the market doesn't pay extra for your memories.
Buyers aren't comparing your home to your lived experience. They're comparing it to other listings in the same suburb, with the same number of bedrooms, similar finishes and the same proximity to schools, shops and amenities.
Your asking price must be based on comparative market analysis (CMA), not sentiment. An experienced estate agent will provide this data, showing you how your home stacks up against others that have recently sold, are currently listed or have failed to sell.
If you've recently replaced your geyser or upgraded the security system, those details may not drastically shift the valuation. Maintenance is expected; it isn't a premium. It's important to differentiate between what buyers view as added value and what they see as simply "up to date."
The Dangers of Overcapitalisation
Many homeowners upgrade their properties over the years - adding a pool, renovating the kitchen, installing high-end finishes. While this can certainly increase appeal, it doesn't always guarantee return on investment.
Overcapitalisation happens when you've invested more into the home than the area can justify. A R3.5 million home in a suburb where most homes sell for R2.8 million will likely struggle to find buyers willing to pay the premium, no matter how luxurious the finishes.
Upgrades should always be aligned with neighbourhood norms. Otherwise, you risk pricing yourself out of your market. A top-of-the-range kitchen in an entry-level area won't necessarily translate to profit. Instead, it may alienate budget-conscious buyers who perceive your property as overpriced.
Working with the right agent
An experienced, local estate agent is key to getting pricing right. They understand the nuance of your suburb, they've seen what sells (and what doesn't) and they have access to property market data that goes beyond what online platforms can offer.
Be cautious of agents who overpromise to win your mandate. Some agents will tell you what you want to hear, not what you need to know. Choose someone who is honest, realistic and data-driven. A trustworthy agent isn't there to flatter you - they're there to get your home sold.
A good agent also understands the buyer psychology specific to your area. What drives interest in Bryanston isn't necessarily the same as in Umhlanga. The ability to tailor pricing strategies accordingly is what separates skilled agents from mere salespeople.
How pricing affects your buyer pool
The price you set doesn't just influence how much you might get. It also affects how many buyers even see your listing.
Online property portals allow buyers to search by price bands. If your home is priced just above a common cutoff point (for instance, R2.1 million instead of R1.995 million), you may miss hundreds of buyers who capped their search at R2 million.
Strategic pricing opens your home to a wider audience. And wider audiences lead to more viewings, better competition and potentially stronger offers.
Your listing doesn't exist in a vacuum. Algorithms, search filters and buyer budgets all impact visibility. Proper pricing doesn't just encourage clicks - it ensures you're showing up in the right searches.
The Sweet Spot: Pricing to invite Offers
The goal isn't just to sell - it's to sell well.
When a property is priced attractively, it creates urgency. Buyers worry that others will snap it up first. This often leads to multiple offers or even full-price offers.
In contrast, a high price invites hesitation. It leads to more questions, more negotiations and often, more disappointment.
Some sellers who priced aggressively even end up receiving more than they hoped for, thanks to the competition created. That's the power of perceived value.
Making peace with the market
The price you want and the price your home is worth, aren't always the same. The sooner you accept that market forces will ultimately decide, the better your chances of selling efficiently and profitably.
If you're not getting any offers or if viewings have dried up, that's feedback. Don't ignore it. Be willing to reassess your strategy quickly. Markets don't care about pride. They reward pragmatism.
Remember, pricing isn't a once-off decision. It's a dynamic part of your sales strategy. If the market changes or buyer interest wanes, revisit the figures. Stay flexible. Stay informed.
The right price is the right start
Selling your home is more than a transaction - it's a journey. But it's one that should begin with realism, not wishful thinking.
By pricing correctly from day one, you set the tone for the entire process. You attract serious buyers. You reduce stress. You shorten your time on the market. And most importantly, you maximise your returns.
Presentation helps. Marketing matters. But the right price? That's what sells a house.
And in the end, what every seller truly wants - is a sold sign, not just a listed one.
Disclaimer: While every effort has been made to ensure the information in this article is accurate and helpful, it is intended for general guidance only. For advice tailored to your unique situation, we recommend speaking directly with a qualified real estate professional who understands your market and goals.
Choose Homes of Distinction to sell your home
Listing your home with Homes of Distinction means partnering with an experienced team that understands the nuances of the real estate market. Our agents are experts in showcasing properties, ensuring that your home receives the attention it deserves. With our proven strategies, high-quality marketing and personalised service, we help you navigate the selling process with ease and efficiency. Trust Homes of Distinction to guide you through every step, from pricing and staging to final negotiations, ensuring a smooth and successful sale of your property. Let us turn your selling goals into reality.
Are you looking to buy or sell your property? Visit our website at https://www.homesofdistinction.co.za/
Sign up for our newsletter: - https://www.homesofdistinction.co.za/newsletter/ or pop by our offices for a chat. Our friendly property practitioners are always available to assist in this regard.
Homes of Distinction CC holds a Fidelity Fund Certificate issued by the Property Practitioners Regulatory Authority (PPRA).
11 Jun 2025
Author Twaambo Chirwa